Skip to main content

Table 5 Comparison of basic demographics and geriatric conditions between elderly dialysis patients and elderly cancer patients

From: Systematic comprehensive geriatric assessment in elderly patients on chronic dialysis: a cross-sectional comparative and feasibility study

Variable

Dialysis Patients (N = 50)

Cancer Patients (N = 292)

p-value

Age, mean (years) (95% CI)

77.1 (75.2–79.0)

75.7 (74.9–76.6)

0.23

Sex, male %

74.0

51.7

0.01

Somatic geriatric conditions

   

Polypharmacy, %

94.6

48.0

<0.001

Moderately-severely malnourished %

32.7 (16/49)

46.0 (104/226)

0.09

Pain, %

24.0 (12/50)

64.8 (83/128)

<0.001

Decubitus, %

2.1 (1/47)

1.4 (2/139)

0.76

Constipation, %

6.3 (3/48)

22.1 (34/154)

0.001

Incontinence for faeces or urine, %

6.4 (3/47)

25.2 (67/266)

0.01

Falls (2 or more falls in last 3 months), %

10.4 (5/48)

12.7 (33/259)

0.65

Charlson co morbidity score, mean (95% CI)

4.6 (0.1–9.1)

5.6 (0.7–10.5)

 

Functional geriatric conditions

   

KATZ total”, mean (95% CI)

2.0 (1.2–2.8)

3.3 (2.9–3.6)

0.01

≥ 1 limitations Katz, %

61.7

79.1

0.01

ADL impairment”, %,

25.0 (12/48)

38.1 (106/278)

<0.001

mean, (95% CI)

0.5, (0.2–0.8)

0.8, (0.6–1.0)

 

IADL impairment”, %,

59.6 (28/47)

76.9 (196/255)

0.01

mean, (95% CI)

1.5, (0.9–2.1)

2.4, (2.2–2.7)

 

Neurosensory deficit, %

44.4 (12/27)

26.0 (71/273)

0.04

Use of walking device, %

31.3 (15/48)

47.9 (134/280)

0.03

Decreased health related quality of life, %

9.8

12.0

NA,^

Euroqol VAS, mean, (95% CI)

61.8 (56.5–67.1)

NA

NA

Psychological geriatric conditions

   

Cognitive impairment (MMSE ≤ 24), %

6.7 (3/45)

NA, *

NA

IQCODE score, mean, (95% CI)

3.1(2.9–3.3) (N = 34)

3.3 (3.2–3.4) (N = 205)

0.09

Cognitive impairment (IQCODE), %

5.9 (2/34)

15.7 (31/197)

0.13

Depressive symptoms, %

24.5

21.3

NA,^^

Delirium, %

0.0

27.4 (62/288)

<0.001

Social geriatric conditions

   

Informal caregiver overburdened, %

84.4 (38/45)

43.8 (49/112)

<0.001

Number of geriatric problems, mean (95%CI)

5.9 (5.3–6.5)

5.3 (4.9–5.7)

0.47

No geriatric conditions found, %

2 (1/51)

8.2 (24/295)

0.03

  1. 95%CI 95% confidence interval.
  2. “KATZ total score 0–15; ADL impairment: KATZ- questions 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8: score 0–6; IADL impairment: KATZ- questions 9–15: score 0–7; higher score means more impaired.
  3. NA Not applicable.
  4. ^Quality of Life was assessed in ESRD patients by EuroQuol-6D and in cancer patients by EuroQuol-5D.
  5. *MMSE unreliable due to many delirious patients.
  6. ^^Depression was assessed in ESRD patients by GDS-15 and in cancer patients by GDS-2.