Skip to main content

Table 1 Model Parameters for Albuminuria Screening, Treatment with Renin-angiotensin System Inhibitors, and Screening and Treatment Costs as Derived from Previous Publications

From: The cost-effectiveness of using chronic kidney disease risk scores to screen for early-stage chronic kidney disease

Model Parameter

Parameter Value

Source

Sensitivity of screening test for moderate albuminuria

0.73

Sarafidis et al. [23]

Specificity of screening test for moderate albuminuria

0.96

Sarafidis et al. [23]

Treatment adherence of persons diagnosed with moderate albuminuria

0.75

Boulware et al. [14]

Treatment effect relative risks (multiplied by baseline rates)

Relative risk of moderate- to severe albuminuria transition for persons receiving treatment

0.45

Strippoli et al. [6]

Relative risk of mortality for persons with moderate albuminuria receiving treatment

0.77

Boulware et al. [14]

Relative risk of annual GFR decrease in persons with for persons with moderate albuminuria receiving treatment

0.67

Agodoa et al. [7] Ruggenenti et al. [8, 9]

Annual QALY decrement from CKD and related complications

 Proteinuria

0.01

Gorodetskaya et al. [24]

 GFR 30–59

0.05

Gorodetskaya et al. [24]

 GFR 15–29

0.07

Gorodetskaya et al. [24]

 GFR <15

0.20

Gorodetskaya et al. [24]

 Stroke, ever

0.582

Meenan et al. [25]

 CA/MI, current year

0.12

Tsevat et al. [26]

 CHD, ever without MI

0.053

Nease et al. [27]

Screening costs (2016 US $)

 Initial visit

88.58

CMS [28]

 Second visit if positive during first visit

69.08

CMS [28]

 One time costs of diagnostic tests to assess for CKD if GFR <60 ml/min/1.73 m2 (2010 $)

 Diabetes or hypertension

382.41

Boulware et al. [14, 20]; CMS [29]; AHRQ [30]

 Neither hypertension nor diabetes: Severe albuminuria and age < 65

2,857.10

Boulware et al. [14, 20]; CMS [29]; AHRQ [30]

 Neither hypertension nor diabetes: Moderate albuminuria and age <65

1,401.40

Boulware et al. [14, 20]; CMS [29]; AHRQ [30]

 Neither hypertension nor diabetes: Age ≥65

964.69

Boulware et al. [14, 20]; CMS [29]; AHRQ [30]

Annual follow-up costs if GFR <60 ml/min/1.73 m2 (2016 US $)

 Specialist visit:

  

 Diabetes

94.15

Boulware et al. [14]; CMS [28]

 No diabetes

85.23

Boulware et al. [14]; CMS [28]

 General practitioner visit

132.88

Boulware et al. [14]; CMS [28]

Annual drug therapy

 ARBs (diabetes)

527.49

Boulware et al. [14]; Rodby et al .[31]; Lewis et al. [32]; Nakao et al. [33]; Jafar et al. [34]; Drug Topics Red Book [35]; AHRQ [36]

 ACE inhibitors (no diabetes)

210.03

 Annual rate at which costs and QALYs are discounted (i.e. reduced)

3%

Weinstein et al. [21]

  1. GFR glomerular filtration rate, ACE angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor, AHRQ Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, ARB angiotensin receptor blocker, CKD chronic kidney disease, CMS Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services