Skip to main content

Table 1 Baseline characteristics of cohorts in all included studies

From: Relationship between renal tissues phospholipase A2 receptor and its serum antibody and clinical condition and prognosis of idiopathic membranous nephropathy: a meta-analysis

Studies

area

PLA2R/anti-PLA2R (+/-)

Testing location

Testing Method

Follow-up (month)

NOS scores

Wang LJ 2016

China

40/16

renal tissues

IFA

12

8

Liu H 2016

China

56/11

renal tissues

IFA

>12

8

Pourcine F 2017

France

69/8

serum

ELISA

168

8

Ramachandran R 2016

India

94/20

serum

ELISA

12

7

Beck LH 2011

Canada

25/10

serum

WB

24

8

Wang J 2017

China

78/13

renal tissues

IFA

15

7

Bech AP 2014

Hollan

34/14

serum

ELISA

60

8

Zhou GY 2017

China

40/16

serum

ELISA

6

7

Qin W 2011

China

49/11

serum

ELISA

>12

5

Oh YJ 2013

Korea

69/31

serum

WB

30

8

Kim YG2015

Korea

41/52

serum

ELISA

24

7

Ruggenenti P 2015

France

81/20

serum

ELISA

12

6

Timmermans SA 2015

Hollan

65/8

serum

IFA

11.3

6

Hofstra JM 2012

Europe

82/28

serum

IFA、ELISA

54

6

Liang Y 2017

China

42/37*

serum

ELISA

12

7

Huang J 2017

China

29/11

serum

IFA

>12

7

Zhang D 2018

China

164/28

serum

ELISA

>13.6

7

Li Q 2018

China

177/73

serum

ELISA

>6

7

  1. Note:IFA indirect immunofluorescence assay, ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, WB Western blotting, * High titer/Low titer